News

DOJ Wants to Extend Oversight of Microsoft to 2009

• By The Associated Press
• May 12, 2006

Microsoft has already agreed to the lengthier scrutiny by the department and 17 states under a proposal that still must be approved by a U.S. judge. The company has struggled with a key provision in the 2002 antitrust settlement requiring it to disclose to its competitors sensitive details about some of its software.

Government lawyers said they were prepared to extend oversight of Microsoft's business activities through 2012 if they deem it necessary. In court papers filed Friday, they described Microsoft's efforts under parts of the settlement as "disappointing" and "not very encouraging," but they also said Microsoft's failures were neither willful nor systematic.

If the longer term is eventually approved by the judge, the U.S. court battle against Microsoft would stretch to at least 11 years -- the age of a middle-schooler -- before it concludes.

During that period, Microsoft will have sold at least five generations of its flagship Windows software. At the same time, Google Inc. has emerged as one of Microsoft's biggest rivals, iPods and BlackBerries have revolutionized portable gadgets and technology executives have made and lost billions.

Lawyers said there was little chance U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly would reject the proposed extension because she has expressed concerns in recent years about Microsoft complying with that part of the settlement, which she has described as among its most important requirements.

Microsoft's top lawyer, Brad Smith, said the extension was "an important step" and gives the company time to finish technical documents that describe the inner workings its software.

Government lawyers said Microsoft's earlier efforts were so dismal even the company agreed it needed to "reset" the program. The Justice Department quoted Renaissance philosopher Niccolo Machiavelli to describe Microsoft's lapses: "He who has not first laid his foundations may be able with great ability to lay them afterwards, but they will be laid with trouble to the architect and danger to the building."

The literary reference was no accident. The judge, Kollar-Kotelly, also had quoted Machiavelli when she approved the antitrust settlement in November 2002. In a passage warning Microsoft to abide by the agreement, she wrote: "Let it not be said of Microsoft that 'a prince never lacks legitimate reasons to break his promise.'"

The top Justice Department lawyer on the case promised the government will vigorously enforce the antitrust settlement.

"This extension will ensure that companies interested in licensing the communications protocols receive the benefit of complete and accurate documentation for the full period of time provided by the court's final judgment," said J. Bruce McDonald, the department's No. 2 antitrust official.

The 2002 antitrust settlement required Microsoft to offer its technology to competitors to build products that seamlessly communicate with computers running Windows software. When the settlement was negotiated, the judge and government lawyers described that requirement as among its most significant provisions toward restoring competition in the technology industry.

The extended scrutiny comes as Microsoft faces intense competition from Google and Yahoo Inc. Microsoft is concerned those companies' Web-based offerings, including e-mail and instant messaging, could threaten its Windows software. Google also is making inroads on the desktop itself, with offerings that include search electronic documents.

Google had informally complained to U.S. and European regulators about the new version of Microsoft's Web browser, which will ship with its upcoming Windows software known as Vista. Google said the browser improperly steers people to Microsoft's search engine instead of Google's more popular technology, but the Justice Department disclosed in its legal papers that it will take no action.

The government said Microsoft's new Web browser respects the choices of consumers and computer makers, and its settings can be easily changed.

McDonald's new boss at the Justice Department, Thomas O. Barnett, has recused himself from the Microsoft case because his former law firm worked for Microsoft.

The 17 states that sued Microsoft with the Justice Department are: California, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Utah, Wisconsin and the District of Columbia.