Pender's Blog

Blog archive

IBM Tries To Ruin Windows 7's Coronation Day

When Microsoft released Vista a few years ago, we trumpeted the launch event with a post in RCPU simply titled, "Vista!" It was, we suppose, meant to convey some sense of excitement about the arrival of the long-awaited operating system that would gracefully lift the desktop crown from the head of XP and reign over us with benevolence and majesty.  

But instead of reigning over us, Vista rained on us. It poured application incompatibilities, outrageous hardware requirements, draconian user access control and all sorts of other big, wet drops of nastiness on our heads. Well, about three years and many, many jokes at Vista's expense later, we find ourselves writing an edition of RCPU for the coronation of Windows 7, which will try to wrest the OS crown from the arthritic but mighty hands of Good King XP.

For this launch, though, we're toning our enthusiasm down considerably. Yes, we've heard that Windows 7 is great. We feel fairly confident based on reviews, reader feedback and analyst babble that Windows 7 will do what Vista couldn't: become the next flagship Microsoft OS and probably the next default OS for personal and corporate computing.

Before we go on, let's restate one thing that everybody who reads RCPU must know: We do not work for Microsoft. We do not promote Microsoft, nor do we serve to promote Microsoft. We are advocates for companies in the Microsoft channel -- our target audience -- but we endeavor always to cover Microsoft objectively and without bias, positive or negative. In a few Web searches, your editor has found comments on other sites suggesting that RCPU is somehow a promotional vehicle for Microsoft and its products. That's just not the case. Most of you know this, of course, but those who don't should learn it.

That's not the reason, though, that we're taking it easy on Windows 7 hype. For one, today's launch is just a formality; many, if not most, of our readers have at least used Windows 7, and there are no doubt large numbers of you who run the OS every day. Beyond that, the launch of a new version of Windows isn't what it used to be. It might still feel a bit like a coronation, but the empire is shrinking.

Windows is still the king of desktop computing, an OS that really competes only against itself (for now) and continues to dominate mainly because IT people and other workers alike are used to it and don't want to go through the hassle and expense of implementing something else. The Microsoft channel also has a lot to do with Windows' success; we're pretty confident in stating that it's easier (and probably cheaper) to find a Microsoft MVP partner who can perform implementations or fix problems than it is to find a Linux or Mac expert.

So, Windows 7, if it's not a repeat of Vista, will probably take over the OS world. But for how long will Microsoft be king of the software mountain? And when will other computing models -- specifically cloud computing -- start to make the OS itself irrelevant, thereby making Windows' dominance a fond memory for Microsoft and its partners?

Just this week, obviously timed for the Windows 7 launch, IBM and Canonical (the distributor of Ubuntu Linux) revealed that they've teamed up to provide a relatively inexpensive cloud-Linux combo for the desktop called IBM Client for Smart Work. Now, we don't really suspect that this offering, intriguing as it is, will make a serious dent in Windows' market share.

In fact, if Windows really is going to cease to be emperor of the desktop at some point, it'll likely die the death of a thousand cuts rather than get bludgeoned in the head with one single offering from a competitor. Google, IBM, Linux, cloud computing in general, even the Mac -- they're all making inroads into the enterprise, and as their ecosystems grow and gain influence, the undeniable expense of Windows compared to other alternatives will start to make less and less sense.

The real strength of Windows, then, is you, the Microsoft partner. It's your expertise, availability and numbers -- along with the familiarity companies have with Windows itself -- that will keep Microsoft on top in the enterprise and make Windows 7 a success (again, as long as Windows 7 isn't another Vista -- nobody could fix that).

Of course, at the same time as they're moving clients to Windows 7, partners also have to be adapting to changing computing models, preparing for the onslaught of cloud and mobile technologies that are already here and will only grow in the future. In the meantime, though, today represents less a day of celebration than a day of commitment.

Partners, the work of pulling Microsoft out of its funk and keeping it on top of the software market (and filling your wallets at the same time) is beginning anew with today's release of Windows 7. It's your job to make sure that Windows is able to step down as emperor when its time comes rather than being deposed. Hopefully Microsoft has given you something to work with in the form of Windows 7. But now is the time to work, not to celebrate.

Have any comments about Windows 7 to add to the huge pile we already have? Send them to lpender@rcpmag.com. Your thoughts are always welcome.

Posted by Lee Pender on October 22, 2009 at 11:27 AM


Reader Comments

Tue, Oct 27, 2009 SteveJ

Seriously, for the "Cloud" to work we need a law that mandates high speed internet for every non-immigrant person living in the United States. Forget Health Care, 4G Internet access is more important.

Tue, Oct 27, 2009 StephenJ

the definition of "cloud" is vaporware. people pretending at IT seem to think it will bring back IT control ala client-server. C-level types think it will bring subscription based software profits, like mmorg and utilities. mmorgs have fat clients and real (profitable) utilities are regulated. Think phones with your contacts/docs on the server, meeting with a client, and being reminded why you @#$% Sprint. Or that 3/4 of Americans don't work for enterprise corps and 3/4 of those can't use the Internet to do their jobs.

Mon, Oct 26, 2009 VictorC Texas

Most people outside the industry do not care what they run on their computer. As long as they can do what they need. MS provides this in home and business. Apple provides this for the iTunes crowd. (Not that simplistic but I am generalizing.) I took Ellison's comments to be more against hype of the cloud than to be against it. I want always access to my information. I am happy synching data. If I need to share all the time then pass it to me through the cloud from my own servers. MS needs to help me provide this. I think that direct access is great but why only on Ent/Ultimate. As Mr. Pender points out, the channel is a strong point for MS. They need to give us a cloud but also the tools to compete against the cloud. Because one solution does not fit everybody.

Mon, Oct 26, 2009 Cape Town, South Afriica

I view of the new Windows 7 is that it is too resource hungry, and the MS Office is outdated and too expensive, We have found using Linux (paid or free versions)very cost effective when combined with the OPEN IBM SYMPHONY solutions, as they open and fully compatible with most of the competition

Sun, Oct 25, 2009 Jason (working for M80, representing Microsoft) Seattle, WA

Interesting article. Mr. Pender makes a lot of good points. He pits IBM's/Canonical's cloud-based solution against Windows 7. However, Windows 7 is merely Microsoft's desktop OS. Microsoft currently has, in beta, their own cloud computing solution to compete with IBM/Canonical (along with the cloud-based solutions of Google and Amazon.com), Windows Azure (http://bit.ly/WindowsAzurePlatform). Azure's planned release date is in November. I can see a lot of potential for cloud computing, but, of course, it doesn't fit every situation.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009 Timmy Earth

Speaking of clouds... Is anyone out there using Zenith for backups? Looking for comments on it.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009 Bob Cozzi Chicago, IL

IBM always tries to do the "me too" thing--but usually waits until long after the window of opportunity closes. The time to have done this was 18 months ago while Vista was still making people angry. The only thing more likely to kill a software package than bloated code, unreliability, and bad marketing is if IBM embraces it (See Lotus, Rational, and others as examples.) Ubuntu is now dead, thanks to IBM.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009 RIM

The truth is that Microsoft really messed up with Vista, and that has opened the door to competitors - and is so logical that competitors are starting to knock. In addition, Microsoft is finally coming out with their fix to Vista via Windows 7. And because the Vista bomb has been such a substantial impact to both Microsoft and consumers, Windows 7 will have to prove itself. And that it is so logical also – and good, actually.

The Cloud is already here. Some prominent research firms are saying how the 2009 global IT spending decline is the worst ever - but that companies are spending in the areas of Software Applications as a Service (via Internet – read that as “Cloud”).

Yes, Ellison speaks out against the Cloud – but do you know that he owns a good hunk of Netsuite, a company that delivers a small business software suite via the Internet ? So, why would he do that. Perhaps because Oracle is so behind in the Cloud arena and he needs to stall interest until he can figure out how to catch up. He has to rationalize how to “cloudify” native Oracle software as well as what to do about Netsuite. These are more than little software tweaks – it is about big disruption to the business model.

Consumers should love it when the competitive markets flow. In the end, competition presents better options for us all.

Lets all scrutinize Windows 7 before we buy ...and realize that the world is much bigger than Windows PC client software.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009

Remember Clouds consist of vapour. Vapour evaporates when the heat is turned up.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009

IBM. OS2. FAIL.

Fri, Oct 23, 2009 Sevjer Maryland

I too have been in the IT industry since before ARPANET (pre Internet) and have seen technologies come and go. I have worked all areas and for the last 10 years have been working security. Anyone who thinks that; no one cares about their computers, their data or their company, better realize Bots don’t care who you are. So my only problem with cloud computing is security. If you do not care if your data is possibly observed, shared, manipulated, than go ahead. For me Windows 7 will work and there are lots of opportunities for those who want to embrace it.

Does that mean I like Microsoft? No, I waited until I got my MCSE, to say it, and I hate Microsoft attitude. I miss the good Novell network days.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009 Fred Flintstone Bedrock, CA

I've been in the IT industry a long, long time ... before networks and before PCs. Does anyone remember X.25 and those that came before? I find it laughable that many forget just how many 'cute' named technologies have come and gone; but it still amazes me that some are so weak minded and insecure that they have to jump on the first bandwagon that comes by. Oh, cloud this and cloud that ... and the every continual O/S debate. I would love to see an Apple O/S that supports as many dissimilar hardware and software platforms that Microsoft does ... I know from experience that when a manufacturer only has to concentrate on making its own products work together the end result is usually a relatively stable and efficient environment. And don't get me wrong, I have a lot of problems with Microsoft and their arrogant management, but then again aren't we all. When will everyone get the idea that until we make what we have work better instead of just reinventing poorer and poorer copies of the same wheel that is all we will continue to do, spin our wheels!

Thu, Oct 22, 2009 Timmy Clouds

I'm ditching my laptop for a Cloudtop. I can use it to connect to my private cloud, or my business cloud, or bridge it to some iternational cloud. I don't need a hard drive or OS, because I'll use my direct WiMax Boot Card or fall back to my MiFi 3G Device in places that aren't Cloud Friendly. In the future we won't even have PCs or Laptops. VDI will run directly from the Cloud (Amazon's Cloud) right down to our phones, TV, and cars. Amen.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009 Chesta

People like to make some kind of illution and tell you that's the future. Cloud? When will it happen? the way people saying it like it is happening now. It is not going to happen. All cloud platforms, including MSFT's own will be never get the business level. The thing people say will happen already happened: EBay, Amozon, Paypal, webmail, online taxing... Those are there for some 15 years. Do you see anthing have changed? I tired of those people pretent they know better than everyone else. Larry Ellision said right. Cloud is a joke! One thing is for sure, when Bing take over Yahoo, and AOL, and ... google will disappear, along with those stupid cloud talk.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009

Ahh, Windows 7. What happened to naming it by year? O yeah XPerence,V"caugh up a lung"ista and now 7? Ought to take a page from Apple. OS X has been around for MANY years! Apple gives it a "service pack" and gives it a animal name! It's still unxi in the background. An old fella once said if it aint broke, then don't fix it. XP still selling and OS X still selling. MS you ought to put that shovel away before someone fills the hole you've dug over the past few years.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009

IBM irrelevant???? Not quite! Power5 and Power6 systems as well as the mainframe are not only alive and well but they are still top dog in business and governments around the planet. And for too many good reasons to list here, their relevance does not go unnoticed by those of us whose job it is to keep cost, power consumption, and TCO low.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009 Forrest Shields Colorado Springs, CO

I really wish the author hadn't waited until 8 paragraphs into the story to start talking about IBM (the headline)! Then he only talks about it for one paragraph. I feel duped.

Thu, Oct 22, 2009 fred beta

AHH HHAHAHAHAHAHAHA... IBM. - do they still make software? so funny. I think the acronym stands for irrelevant business machines.

Add Your Comments Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above