Pender's Blog

Blog archive

Why Should We Suddenly Want Tablet Computers?

It's understandable that folks went a little nuts over the Apple iPad. Apple has, after all, brought us the iPod, the iPhone and the iPod Touch over the last decade or so, and those are mostly pretty cool (and very successful) gadgets.

But besides the fact that the iPad looks ridiculous, it has also started a flood of articles about how tablet computing is going to take over the world. We don't get why that would happen. But first, the hype. Apparently, the iPad has sparked a tablet "war" (beware: a video featuring an Australian accent plays in this link), with every big vendor under the sun, including Microsoft developing its weapon for battle.

None other than the venerable Atlantic has more or less predicted the death of the book as collateral damage in the tablet war. But haven't tablets been around forever, with very little pick-up from users? And would anybody really spend $500 or more for a fancier way to read? We already have smart phones, netbooks, laptops, music players. Where does this tablet thing fit in? The ones we've seen aren't phones and don't even have real keyboards. What's the point?

Apparently, one would-be tablet producer's answer to that question is (paraphrasing here), "Well, uh, actually...I don't know." No, really! Check this out from Australia's Brisbane Times:

"Ruslan [Kogan, an Australian entrepreneur and tablet-producer wannabe] admits he doesn't know how people will use it or whether he'd actually use one himself.

'It's one of those devices where I'm wondering what people will do with it...This is one Kogan product that I don't know if I'd actually use it for myself, because I've got an Android phone and a Kogan netbook and they pretty much fulfill all my mobile needs...' Kogan says."

But Kogan goes on to say that he's just sure that there's demand for a tablet. After all (our words now, not his), Apple's making one, right? If Apple's making one, it must be a good idea. Right? Oh, yes, by all means, let's bring to market a fairly expensive gadget that even its potential manufacturers don't see an immediate, overly compelling use for.  That makes a lot of sense. [/sarcasm]

Do you want a tablet computer? Why? Sound off at lpender@rcpmag.com.

Posted by Lee Pender on March 10, 2010 at 11:35 AM


Reader Comments

Thu, Mar 11, 2010 David Bell Baltimore, Maryland

I am a heavy ipod touch user. I also have increasingly poor eyesight. I very much look forward to getting an iPAD, especially for the Kindle and Barnes and Noble e-reader apps. I also use the alarm clock app and stopwatch/timer feature on a daily basis. Too bad there is no multitasking, however. How hard can it be to enable simple email reading and listening to Pandora streamed Radio at the same time?

Thu, Mar 11, 2010 Vince Chicago

The fact that the iPad runs iPhone apps and is based on the iPhone OS (and not OS X) indicates that it's not a device that will have real computing power, so it's not something that can replace a laptop for business. It reminds me of the old Apple days when they sold computers to students and families, but they were never able to really broke into the professional market. Lenovo has a ThinkPad W500 with a touch screen option and I'm wondering how much demand that will generate.

Wed, Mar 10, 2010 Andy Elyria, OH

I haven't decided if I will order an iPad yet, but it is very tempting. Tablet computing needs minimal weight, durability, decent local storage, bright 'large enough fast screen, great applications (and open SDK), good wireless performance and an interface that eliminates the need for a super precise pointing mechanism. The iPad looks like it delivers on all those things. As others have said, it's not a platform for creating content - it's a platform for accessing content - both for quick look ups, and general web browsing/entertainment. It matches up well with the strength of the internet...

Wed, Mar 10, 2010 Brian B

Oh yeah - I'm betting that iPad 2.0 will have all the kinks worked out (adding Flash support maybe), better business apps, and a better price point. Then they won't be able to ship them fast enough.

Wed, Mar 10, 2010 Brian B

I spend A LOT of time editing photos from the events I went to over the weekend and making videos. I sit on my couch with my laptop,listen to music, and do tons of cropping and editing. I never wanted a tablet, but now I think it would be great to kickback and do all my photo editing without using that small trackpad below the keyboard. Using my hands would be so much nicer. That said, I'm not spending $500 for the iPad. Also, my Mom is someone who would probably love the iPad b/c she is a simpleton with her laptop. I would buy her an iPad just so I don't have to be her tech support anymore. But she spends HOURS on Yahoo games and other game sites. She loves those stupid games like Bookworm, etc. Since iPad doesnt' support Flash, that's a deal killer for her.

Wed, Mar 10, 2010 Dave

Techies hate tablets. Grandma will love it. Bookmark this article, read it again in five years, and laugh. Comparing windows tablets to the iPad is like comparing windows mobile to the iPhone. You can make something work like windows, or you can make something work for human beings. I am not an Apple fan and will probably not get an iPad. But I can see a tablet of some sort in my not to distant future.

Wed, Mar 10, 2010

I have found using a tablet to be quite beneficial. Combined with the One Note application hand written notes taken at meetings and other activities can be organized and searched easily. With a separate keyboard and mouse and the leaned tablet it is more comfortable than working with a laptop small keyboard.

Wed, Mar 10, 2010 Rob

The iPad doesn't represent why people, like myself, are looking forward to tablets. In fact, Apple did a rather lazy job coming out with their tablet product. In truth, they could have forwarded the technology by years if they had wanted to make a quality product. It's the potential of tablets that no one has tapped into. This article is one of the best I've seen that summarizes why people want tablets: http://besttabletreview.com/the-a-zs-of-tablets-why-tablets-hold-so-much-potential/

Wed, Mar 10, 2010

Little to no interest in 'tablets'. I'm often traveling needing something that will serve my office/dev needs, and a tablet just ain't it. Need a real k/b, mouse, decent size screen (13 or better), mem/processing pwr, smart card reader etc - ie a real laptop. Oh and,, NO, I'm not gonna run all my apps in the cloud, some cloud storage though, yes. Smartphone - ok, Laptop - definitely. Tablet - No use to me.

Add Your Comments Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above