Pender's Blog

Blog archive

PC Makers Offering Vista-XP Downgrades

Oh, we try hard, so hard, not to pile on with this Vista stuff. It's just that every time we think it's getting old to talk about what a, uh, "mitigated success" (yes, we're being kind) Vista has been, something else comes out that demonstrates that this operating system is about as popular as New Coke was once upon a time. (By the way, thank you, Internet and Wikipedia, for providing us with more information than we ever thought existed on New Coke. What was life like before the Internet? We don't remember...and we don't care.)

Anyway, it wasn't enough, apparently, for Dell to start selling PCs with XP (rather than Vista) pre-loaded. Now Dell, HP and Lenovo are all offering downgrades to XP for customers who buy machines with Vista pre-installed.

The linked article says that most of the downgrades are primarily for business customers rather than the retail set; the anecdotal evidence we've heard suggests that neither category of customer is happy with Vista, but the critical point here seems to be that Vista has drawn reactions not so much of apathy but almost of disgust and contempt. It's one thing for businesses to ignore a major Windows upgrade; it's another for them to actively dislike it.

Of course, we still maintain that we'll all be running Vista eventually, but with Office under attack from multiple sources, open source getting lots of press and the European Union putting the hammer down on the company, it sure would be nice for Microsoft if it could point to Vista as a bright spot in its current cloudy skies. Alas, that's not really possible.

Any leftover thoughts on Vista? It always seems to be a popular topic. Send your musings my way at lpender@rcpmag.com.

Posted by Lee Pender on September 25, 2007 at 6:53 PM


Reader Comments

Tue, Oct 2, 2007 Manny Borges Worcester

I have been working with systems since the early 90's.
And through that time I have been a consistent fan of MS products.
Not so with Vista.
I Beta tested it, I used the end product for two months, and am now happily back on XP.

You would think MS would have learned their lesson after the BOB fiasco.

Don't let marketing make your product decisions and don't change a functional and winning solution.

Wed, Sep 26, 2007 Deon Florida

I do client work for end-users, regular people. I've been asked more than once by multiple clients to downgrade (would you call it a downgrade?) their new purchase to XP. They pay me for the hours it takes for me to format a brand new computer, install XP, hunt down the drivers, etc. I've had computer friends of mine initially swear by Vista and then later downgrade themselves back to XP, I just smile and say told you so. I've known since the Beta's of Vista that it'd be a problematic OS, I've run Beta's of XP before it was released and knew that OS would succeed. The speed issues, compatibility issues, and the interface issues. It's like they took an eccentric graphics artist and through them at Vista and said "go nuts with it, change whatever you want for whatever reason". I mean, why radically change a tried and proven interface. Sigh.

Wed, Sep 26, 2007 Omar Flint, MI

Manufacturers are being forced to do this by customer demand. I am a Microsoft partner, and am definitely not sold on Vista. I personally installed it on machine and within 2 week the profile became corrupted and I could find no way to repair it. I tell my customers they need 1 but preferably 2GB of memory to consider getting Vista, because any less and performance will definitely be sluggish. Vista has a cool look and is snazzy and all, but there is not enough of an improvement to warrant endorsing the upgrade to clients.

Tue, Sep 25, 2007 Bob Richland, WA

I have run Vista at home for several months and have zero compalints. It doesn't crash, all my oerioherals came across, it is reasonably fast and I like the interface. I can understand the corporate issue, but for home use it has been fine. Your mileage may differ.

Add Your Comments Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above